Lucky, which is the best alternative to Craigslist Personals. Unlike other dating apps, it's totally anonymous, so a selfie is all you need to get started. Once you’re in, your first hookup is only a few hours away. Get Lucky now! - Luckyapp.co. It's well known that many personals sites like Craigslist personals have been closed after the FOSTA bill was passed by Congress. People have been looking for local free hookups sites and personals like Craigslist personals since March.